Stewdio Case Study: Cold Email Results for an AI Creative Studio, With Up to 55% of Replies Positive (2026)

TL;DR: Stewdio, an AI-powered creative studio and marketing agency, ran cold email outbound with us from May to August 2026. Across 18 campaigns we reached 5,640 leads, sent 15,218 emails and got 184 replies. 33 replies were positive: leads asking for details or agreeing to a conversation. The strongest segments did far better than the average: niche segments turned 55% of their replies positive, the Diwali festive campaigns 42%, and the best single campaign 67%. The biggest lesson was that the campaign with the highest reply rate produced no positive replies at all.
I run ThynkGrowth, a signal-led outbound agency based in Bangalore, India. Before ThynkGrowth I built the outbound engine behind a $6.12M quarterly pipeline for a 70-person BDR team at an enterprise SaaS company. Stewdio is a program where reply tagging told a very different story from reply counts, which makes it worth writing up in full.
The client: Stewdio
Stewdio is an AI-powered creative studio and marketing agency. Its team has worked on campaigns for brands including Tanishq, Van Heusen, Britannia, CCD and Flipkart. The goal for outbound was simple to state and hard to do: start conversations with marketing leaders at brands that buy creative work.
How the program was set up
Everything ran from Stewdio's own Smartlead account, with three-email sequences throughout. Instead of one big list, the program tested segments side by side:
- SaaS and B2B technology companies
- Niche segments with a tight, specific buyer
- Enterprise brands
- D2C and consumer brands
- Hospitality and financial services
- Diwali festive campaigns for Indian jewellery, apparel, FMCG, logistics, electronics and corporate gifting brands
The Diwali campaigns used a hiring signal to prioritise accounts: Indian brands that had brought in a new VP or Director of Marketing in the previous 90 days, timed to land while Diwali creative budgets were being planned.
Stewdio's cold email results
| Metric | May to August 2026 |
|---|---|
| Campaigns | 18 |
| Leads contacted | 5,640 |
| Emails sent | 15,218 |
| Replies | 184 |
| Positive replies | 33 |
| Positive reply rate | 18% of replies overall |
Which segments had the highest positive reply rate?
| Segment | Leads | Replies | Positive | Positive reply rate (of replies) | Of leads contacted |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Niche segments | 552 | 22 | 12 | 55% | 2.17% |
| Diwali festive campaigns | 729 | 12 | 5 | 42% | 0.69% |
| Enterprise brands | 1,077 | 24 | 7 | 29% | 0.65% |
| Best single campaign (niche) | 211 | 9 | 6 | 67% | 2.84% |
Source: Stewdio's Smartlead account, lead tags across 18 outbound campaigns. Positive means the lead asked for details or agreed to a conversation. Full results for every campaign, May to August 2026.
For context, Apollo's 2026 summary of Sales.co research, covering over 2 million cold emails, puts the average at 14.1% of replies positive. Stewdio's overall 18% sat above that average, and its niche segments ran at nearly four times it.
The niche segments were the standout. With 552 leads between them, they produced 12 positive replies, more than a third of the program's total from under a tenth of its leads.
Why did the highest reply rate get zero positive replies?
One SaaS campaign posted the highest reply rate in the account, 3.31% per email, and looked like the obvious winner. When every reply was tagged, none of them were positive. Most were neutral, the bucket where out-of-office messages and auto-replies land.
Meanwhile a niche campaign with 9 replies turned 6 of them positive. If Stewdio had scaled by reply rate, it would have put more volume into the campaign that produced nothing.
What made the best segments work?
- A tight buyer. The niche segments were built around one specific type of company, so the messaging could be specific to that buyer rather than to "marketing leaders" in general.
- Timing to the buyer's calendar. The Diwali campaigns reached Indian brands while their biggest creative budgets of the year were still being planned.
- A signal behind the list. A new VP or Director of Marketing in the last 90 days is someone likely to be reviewing agencies.
- Credibility the buyer recognises. Stewdio's team history with well-known consumer brands gave the emails proof a marketing leader could check.
What this case study shows
- Sort by positive replies, not replies. The best-looking campaign by reply rate produced nothing. The best by positive replies came from a list of 211 leads.
- Test segments in parallel, then commit. Running several segments side by side gave a clear answer within weeks.
- Narrow the segment. Niche segments turned 55% of replies positive, against 29% for the broad enterprise list.
- Tag every reply. Without tagging, the program would have scaled the wrong campaign.
Methodology
- Source: Stewdio's Smartlead account, full results for all 18 prospecting campaigns, May to August 2026.
- Leads contacted: unique people who received at least one email, in three-email sequences.
- Replies: every reply Smartlead recorded, including out-of-office messages.
- Positive replies: replies tagged as interested in Smartlead, such as a request for details or a conversation.
- Nothing excluded: every prospecting campaign is counted. Two automated out-of-office follow-up sequences are left out because they re-contact the same leads.
Run outbound like this
ThynkGrowth is a signal-led outbound GTM agency based in Bangalore, India, and a Clay Solutions Partner. Our GTM engineers build outbound programs like Stewdio's inside each client's own accounts for B2B companies: segment tests, signal-based lists, messaging and reply tagging. If you are comparing partners, what a cold email agency does and how to choose one is a fair place to start.
What results did Stewdio get from cold email?
From May to August 2026, Stewdio's outbound sent 15,218 emails across 18 campaigns and got 184 replies, 33 of them positive. Niche segments turned 55% of their replies positive, and the best single campaign reached 67%.
Does cold email work for creative and marketing agencies?
It can, when the list is narrow and the proof is recognisable. Stewdio's niche segments turned 55% of replies positive, and its Diwali festive campaigns, timed to when Indian brands plan their biggest creative budgets, turned 42% positive.
Why did Stewdio's highest reply rate campaign get no positive replies?
Most of its replies were neutral, such as out-of-office messages, which count as replies in sending tools. A 3.31% reply rate per email produced no interested leads, which is why the program was judged on positive replies instead.
What is a good positive reply rate for cold email?
A Sales.co analysis of over 2 million cold emails found that 14.1% of replies are positive on average. Stewdio's program overall reached 18%, its Diwali festive campaigns 42%, and its niche segments 55%, nearly four times the average.
Related reading
Want to find the segment where your outbound converts?
We build signal-led outbound inside your own accounts: infrastructure, signals, lists, copy and the rep workflow. Book a free strategy call and we will map your plan.
Book a free strategy call